
In March, ABC made the unprecedented decision to pull an already-filmed season of “The Bachelorette” from the air just three days before it was set to premiere. The cancellation came after an unsettling video surfaced of the former lead, Taylor Frankie Paul, involved in a physically violent domestic dispute with her ex-partner, Dakota Mortensen.
From a public relations perspective, this is more than just reality TV drama; It’s a case study on how not to handle a PR crisis. What unfolded after the cancellation was a series of communications missteps that serve as an important lesson for brands.
Choosing a Spokesperson for “The Wrong Reasons”
Originally chosen as The Bachelorette after her rise to fame on “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” (SLOMW) despite controversy she stirred up there, Paul was an unexpected choice from the start. The center of this crisis is a foundational mistake: ABC built an entire season, and promotional campaign, around a volatile figure with a known history of domestic abuse.
Despite publicly accessible records and a SLOMW episode depicting the domestic dispute and Paul’s arrest in 2023, the network vastly underestimated the risk of elevating Paul as the face of the long-beloved franchise. From a reputational standpoint, the lead of a show serves, in a way, as the brand’s spokesperson. Because Paul was involved in a major public scandal, blame shifted to ABC’s decision to choose her as their lead and as a result, public scrutiny shifted to the network.
Will You Accept This Apology?
After the video of the domestic dispute went viral, a spokesperson for Disney Entertainment Television, the parent company of ABC, issued a statement announcing the season would not be aired. Although the statement came quickly after the video circulated, the public viewed it more as an act of damage control, rather than an authentic response.
ABC remained relatively quiet immediately after the cancellation was announced. When ABC did speak out, their response was short, leaving many with unanswered questions.
“In light of the newly released video just surfaced today, we have made the decision to not move forward with the new season of ‘The Bachelorette’ at this time, and our focus is on supporting the family.”
This Changes Everything
The poor and inauthentic statements from the network and its parent company resulted in an ineffective and failed crisis response.
Rather than taking ownership of the fact that they had prior knowledge of the incident, offering clarity on their casting process and providing transparency, ABC’s response was curt and ineffectual. What’s more? Promotional content for Paul’s Bachelorette season remains on ABC’s social media channels a month later.
The network’s silence was met with increased speculation, rumors and criticism, damaging its reputation and creating narratives outside of its control.
The PR Takeaways
The real cost of ABC’s poor crisis management is the lasting impact this could have on its reputation. The lack of a clear response statement has led to a decline in audience trust, which could ultimately cause the deterioration of the franchise, which has been successful for two decades.
So, what can brands do to avoid these missteps?
- Bring a knowledgeable and proven PR team in early in the process of a large campaign and ensure there is a strong communications plan in place, including a crisis strategy.
- Thoroughly vet spokespeople, including background checks and reviews of social media presence.
- Prioritize substance over speed in crisis responses. Your audience wants a thoughtful explanation, not a Band-Aid statement.
- If you’re not in control of your brand’s reputation, someone else is. By acknowledging crisis situations with thoughtful, authentic statements, you minimize speculation and false narratives.
In a moment where a clear, values-driven response could have stabilized the brand, a brand known for a reality show where no one is afraid to speak up, ABC failed to provide that clarity. If your brand is facing a reputational threat, we can help. Reach out to us at https://www.kimballpr.com/contact.








