Behind the Picket Lines: Communicating in Times of Employee Discord

Years ago, autumn was not just about pumpkin spice, leaf peeping, back to school and football. It was also celebrated as the end of summer’s re-runs with a new line-up of fresh television shows released each September. While those days are long gone with the advent of streaming platforms, this year looked a bit different. We were back to reruns.

The Writers Guild of America was on strike for more than five months, forcing a rapid halt to the production of new content for Hollywood. Then, its resolution in late September was followed with a strike by the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, who have been behind the picket lines for more than 100 days now. Both unions were and are respectively pushing for long-term pay, control over artificial intelligence and employment consistency.

And it is not just Hollywood on strike these days. Roughly 46,000 workers with the United Auto Workers union in Kentucky, Michigan and Texas found themselves behind picket lines this fall demanding improved wages and benefits.

These strikes, coupled with employee push back on employer demands for a return to office point to the fact that today’s employees have a bigger voice, and their actions are forcing employers to listen. From a communications perspective, unhappy or disgruntled employees who take their complaints public can lead to a brand reputation problem. Fortunately, a smart, proactive plan for internal and external company communications can help diffuse situations and paint your company in the best light.

Best Practices for Communicating Amid Employee Issues

While a strike, social media backlash to a corporate return-to-work mandate, or round of layoffs may burden and inconvenience leadership with staffing shortages, overtime pay and/or mounting legal fees, the reputational damage could be the most destructive –  particularly if the press gets wind of it.

One of the best ways to get ahead of reputational issues related to employee discord is to work with a public relations team to build a comprehensive plan for internal and external communications. This way, leadership is better prepared and will have direction on how to maintain good communication with employees, vendors, stakeholders and the community. Among other best practices, leadership should consider the following in a time of employee discord:

  • Keep an open dialogue with employees.

Employees want to feel heard. With many employer return-to-work mandates, employees did not feel their needs were being considered.

Many employees like the cost savings and flexibility of remote work and feel they are more productive as a result. Employers who feel strongly about employees returning to work should communicate with employees rather than simply mandating a change. They should make the case for employees as to why a return to the office is necessary and even consider acknowledging the sacrifice employees made to work from home during the pandemic. After having that dialogue, leadership might determine that offering an incentive to bring employees back or a hybrid option could help maintain or improve employee morale and prevent discord.

  • Control emotions and cool tempers.

Communications between the U.A.W. and auto manufacturing plants have become heated with Stellantis issuing a press release that began with the fighting words, “we are outraged.”

Aside from pride, big dollars are at stake, causing emotions and tempers to run hot. But a good public relations professional can help a leadership team craft messaging that carries a human element and reflects a more considered approach. A public relations team would caution executives from letting anger show through, particularly in negotiation-related communications.

  • Keep your media team updated with all developments to avoid surprises.

Whether it is a salacious email leak connected to a member of the leadership team or a negative social media post gaining momentum, it is critical to keep your public relations team updated regarding developments during a time of employee discord.

You never know what will erupt into headlines and damage the reputation of your company. If your public relations team is made aware of the situation with time to spare, they can proactively prepare a plan and smart messaging to try to prevent a situation from spiraling out of control.

While a good public relations team may not be able to do anything about the employee discord forcing reruns upon us this fall, they can help company leadership better communicate – and recognize the value of open and frequent dialogue. Hopefully, we will see these workers and executives come to common ground soon, but until then, let us encourage a focus on good communication.

Leave a comment